"A faith that can not survive collision with the truth is not worth many regrets" - Arthur C. Clarke

Truth-Tests for Choosing a Worldview

- R. Totten - (c) '04

Preliminary Issues
After considering the main worldviews held by most all of mankind, how does one go about deciding which one is best, which must be false, and which one, if any, has a high probably of being true? (Truth is that which matches up with reality.)

To begin with, we must assume that something exists. Every full-orbed worldview recognizes this. Next, we must assume that we can actually know something, and that we can think true thoughts. A reasonable starting-point for this might well be that of Descartes' reasoning: "I think, therefore I am." This demonstrates that we do exist, and that we know something which is self-evidently true ...a reasonable starting point.

Along with assuming that we can know something, come the three laws of logical thought, which are: the law of identity, the law of opposites, and the law of non-contradiction.

If these laws of thought are denied, then all meaningful thought and communication is destroyed, and our existence proceeds into nonsense and nihilism.

The Three Truth-Tests
Logical thinking allows us to list three distinctive qualities which test the truthfulness of any worldview:

FIRST, an adequate worldview must be consistent within itself, and non-contradictory. Any contradiction is a definite indication that the worldview contains at least some untruth; And if the contradiction involves an essential element of the worldview, then the worldview must be false, having failed the first truth-test.

SECOND, an adequate worldview must fit basically all the relevant facts and data of reality and human experience. The worldview which accounts for the greatest number of facts, with the fewest difficulties, has the highest probability of being a worldview which is true. A worldview which is inconsistent with human experience and with the empirical facts of history, nature and the universe, fails the second truth-test.

THIRD, an adequate worldview must be subjectively satisfactory and livable on an every-day basis. We must ask: When a man is done talking and "philosophizing" about the nature of his worldview, can he consistently live it out, and does he actually practice it in his daily life? ...If not, then the actions of his life reveal his true inner conviction of the untruth of his professed worldview ...that it is not livable, and therefore, by his actions he rejects his own worldview --so that it fails the third truth-test.

Study any worldview, such as those addressed on this web-site, and evaluate it with these truth-tests in mind.

* * *


Further Discussion:

Questions or Comments? :

Directory to TestingWorldviews.com

Home Page

The Worldview of Naturalism
The Worldview of Eastern Pantheism
The Worldview of Theism
The Foundation of Science is The Biblical Worldview
Science Facts Confirm the Bible
Archaeology Confirms Biblical History
Prophecy Proves the Bible's Authority
$1,000,000 Prize for Abiogenesis, Evolution ... & A Challenge for "Scriptures"
Abiogenesis : Hopeful Distortions and Spontaneous Generation Redux
Creation vs Evolution: Articles and Discussion
Christ's Resurrection ...Fact or Fiction?
How You Can Be Saved
Who We Are
What We Believe
Links to Other Biblical Apologetics Sites